Last night I was lazy and I took the kiddies to Wendy's for dinner because we were running errands and I wanted them to be happy while they waited in the car for me to run into various places. Whenever Dustin gets a drink he always wants "Black Sprite" meaning rootbeer. I always think it is hilarious that he calls rootbeer "Black Sprite" and I always giggle to myself when I hand it to him. Last night, however, having Dustin call his rootbeer "Black Sprite" triggered a memory that has always stuck with me. I think it is because I was shocked that someone could be that uptight, or maybe it was because I am busy getting everyone ready to go on vacation and I am exhausted. Whatever the case, here is the story. . . . what do you think?
When Abby was 4 years old I had put her into a FANTASTIC preschool. I had spent hours researching which preschool to register her in and I woke up bright and early on registration day to go and register her in the amazing school. I LOVED this preschool. I loved that they had 3 different rooms that they cycled the kids though and taught them different things in those rooms. I loved that they had 2 way mirrors so that I could stand outside of the classroom and watch how she was doing. I loved her teachers and how they interacted with Abby.
One day, I was a few minutes late picking Abby up from preschool. When I went inside, the director of the school, the principal and the teacher were all waiting with her. I thought that they were all just waiting to go home and had decided to keep Abby company while she waited for me. As I walked into the room, they all stood up and introduced themselves. I greeted them happily and gave Abby a hug while apologizing for being late. They said it wasn't a problem, but that was not why they were there. They then proceeded to tell me that there was a little girl who had recently started going to the preschool and she was black. They then told me that Abby had been playing with a toy and the girl had taken it from her. This had upset Abby and so she went and told the teacher that the "Black" girl had taken her toy.
THIS IS WHAT HAD CAUSED ALL OF THEM TO GREET ME THAT DAY!!!
The principal made it very clear that they would not tolerate ANY racism in the classroom and that Abby's behaviour was unacceptable. I was shocked!!! These ladies were lecturing me about the fact that Abby had called this little girl "black". They started lecturing me on racial tolerance and teaching it to my kids. After about 5 minutes I started to get bored of being lectured because I didn't think that Abby had done anything wrong. So, I told them what I thought. I told them that I realized that there is going to be diversity in a classroom. I told them that while it may not be right to label people based on the color of their skin, sometimes when you are 4 and you can't remember a person's name because you have seen them only once before and you are asked to try and name that person, maybe you try to describe them instead. I would think that the first thing that would pop into a 4 year old's (or 40 year old's) head to describe this one little girl who was the only one who was black would be to mention the color of her skin so that the teacher wouldn't be confused as to who it was that Abby was talking about. I also mentioned to the teachers that Abby did not actually call the girl "black" to her face and so the necessary apology that they wanted to enforce on Abby would not be acceptable. I also asked the ladies if there had ever been any other problems with Abby, at all. They told me "no". I then told them that this was not going to be something that I would be discussing with Abby because I didn't feel as though she had done something wrong. I then took Abby by the hand and took her home.
I know that I can be obnoxious and I am REALLY stubborn when it comes to defending my kids. However, I am curious to know what you guys think? What would you have done? Do you think that the teachers were right? Let me know!
invisible apple cake
3 days ago
6 comments:
Have you ever read the book "NurtureShock" (Po Bronson)? There's a chapter on talking to kids about race that your blog post made me think of. In fact, hmm...
http://www.newsweek.com/id/214989
Anyway. I think the preschool staff was way out of line. I think Abby sounds like an entirely developmentally-appropriate 4-year old, which the staff should know. The whole thing sounds really silly to me.
So consider yourself validated. :)
They should have taken the chance to show Abby other ways to describe the girl..."Oh, you mean the girl in the yellow dress with curly hair?" And left it at that.
I think talking about race with kids is important, but age 4 is a little young.
I agree with you and the comments left. They took a teaching moment and turned it into something it shouldn't have been.
Holy that is ridiculous. I think sometimes people way over react when it comes to political correctness. Would they have pulled you aside if she described the girl as "that blonde girl"? Of course not. She is black. There's nothing wrong with a 4-year-old noticing that. It's not like she is capable of thinking that the girl took her doll BECAUSE she was black. I'm glad you handled it the way you did. Some people are stupid.
Megan -
You are so right. Those people are the worst kind of bigots - so busy hiding behind their own perverted idea of political correctness that they cannot see reality. They likely would have preferred that Abby used that obnoxious term "African-American" - wrongly used = ALWAYS - to describe a black person who almost always has no connection whatever with Africa.
The attitude of those school people was abominable, and it is too bad that there wasn't some authority to whom you could report them.
Ashley
What's the problem? Was the girl black? Like Jamie said they would have no problem if she had described the girl as blond! It's not like she used a racial slur. Being tolerant and not racist doesn't equal being colour blind. Kids are bound to notice that other children's skin is a different colour than theirs. That's not a problem. It's when they start to think they are better than someone else because of skin colour, or sex or the size of their car or the fact that they can pretend that they don't notice skin colour that you have a problem! So ignorant.
Post a Comment